7 Lessons from Breaking Every Podcasting Rule to Hit 40 Million Downloads

In the world of podcasting, success often comes from zigging when others zag. Today, we're exploring Gary Arndt's unconventional path to creating the "Everything Everywhere Daily" podcast - a show that ranks #1 in US history podcasts and has secured top 10 positions in 63 different countries. Starting after COVID wiped out 95% of his travel photography income, Gary launched a daily educational show that now generates substantial five-figure monthly revenue and 1.5 million downloads per month.

Beyond his podcasting success, Gary has built a dedicated community of "Completionists" - superfans who've listened to all 1,700+ episodes of his show. His journey from creating a Google Doc with 100 show ideas to writing what he calls "2000-word term papers" daily offers valuable insights for anyone looking to build a sustainable podcast. In this post, we'll unpack seven crucial lessons from Gary's experience that challenge conventional podcasting wisdom while delivering proven results.

1. Ignore "Niching Down" When It Doesn't Serve Your Vision  

Building a successful podcast doesn't always require specialization. For Gary Arndt, success came from doing the opposite - creating a show that deliberately covers everything from history and geography to mathematics and science. Rather than limiting himself to one topic, Gary embraced variety, making his show title "Everything Everywhere" a deliberate statement against conventional advice.

This approach allowed Gary to create what podcasting experts might consider impossible - a show with broad appeal that still maintains depth and substance. By focusing on quality research and presentation rather than topic restrictions, Gary's show attracts curious listeners across numerous interest categories. The lack of niche became his niche, allowing him to stand out in a crowded podcasting landscape dominated by highly specialized shows.

2. Create the Show You Want to Listen To  

The most successful podcasts often come from a creator-first perspective - not what you want to talk about, but what you genuinely want to hear. Gary emphasizes working backwards from the listener experience, creating content he himself would eagerly consume. This subtle shift in perspective means focusing less on your interests as a creator and more on the quality of information and entertainment you're providing.

While many daily podcasters produce quick, off-the-cuff content, Gary invests hours researching and writing substantial scripts for each episode. "I write a 2000 word term paper every day, basically," he explains. This commitment to quality means listeners receive genuinely educational content rather than casual conversations or surface-level overviews. When you create content that meets your own high standards, you naturally attract an audience that shares your values.

3. Calculate Your Subscriber Value  

Converting a podcast from hobby to business requires understanding the economics behind listener acquisition. Gary's approach evolved into a precise calculation method that guides all his marketing decisions. By determining that each subscriber generates between $10-$14 annually through ad revenue, he established a clear ceiling for acquisition costs.

This data-driven approach allows him to confidently invest in growth, knowing that as long as he acquires listeners for less than their lifetime value (typically $1-3 per subscriber), each marketing dollar generates positive returns. Unlike most podcasters who guess at marketing effectiveness, Gary's mathematical framework enables strategic decisions about where and how much to spend on promotion.

4. Invest in App-Based Advertising, Not Social Media  

The path to podcast growth requires promotion where podcast listeners already exist. Gary discovered through extensive testing that social media marketing produced poor results despite conventional wisdom. "I've completely ceased promoting the show on social media because it doesn't work," he explains, noting that even building 18,000 TikTok followers failed to significantly increase podcast listenership.

Instead, Gary focuses his promotional budget on podcast app advertising - platforms like Overcast, Podcast Addict, and Podbean where users are already actively seeking audio content. This targeted approach delivers better results by meeting potential listeners in environments where they're primed to subscribe to new shows. For podcasters with limited marketing budgets, focusing on in-app promotion provides the most direct path to finding new subscribers.

5. Focus on Audio Excellence Before Expanding to Video  

Success in podcasting comes from mastering one format before diversifying. When Gary started his show, he concentrated exclusively on audio quality and content, resisting the pressure to immediately expand to YouTube or other video platforms. This focus allowed him to perfect his process and build an audience without dividing his attention across multiple formats.

Gary notes important advantages to the audio-first approach: "CPMs are much higher on audio and you don't have to worry about the algorithm." Unlike YouTube creators who often find themselves chasing trending topics after one video succeeds, podcasters can maintain consistent content strategies without algorithm dependency. This consistency builds listener loyalty and allows for predictable growth planning.

6. Create a Fan Community Around Your Content  

Sustainability in podcasting extends beyond just creating regular content - it requires building genuine connections with your audience. Gary's "Completionist Club" celebrates listeners who have consumed every episode, creating a sense of belonging and recognition that transforms casual listeners into dedicated advocates.

Gary further strengthens this community by ending each episode with a listener review reading, encouraging more reviews while making featured listeners feel valued. This approach creates a virtuous cycle where engaged listeners promote the show through word-of-mouth, the most trusted form of podcast discovery. By acknowledging and celebrating your most dedicated fans, you create a support system that sustains your show during growth plateaus.

7. Accept That Real Success Takes Time  

Transforming a podcast from startup to sustainable business requires patience and persistent effort. Gary's experience shows that meaningful results typically require at least 18 months of consistent publishing. "After 18 months, I was making some money. And then by two and a half years, I was making quite a bit of money," he explains, highlighting the realistic timeline for podcast monetization.

During this extended growth phase, focus on these key elements:

• Consistency in publishing schedule

• Gradual improvement in content quality

• Building direct relationships with listeners

• Testing different promotional channels

• Gathering and implementing feedback

• Refining your unique approach

• Developing relationships with advertisers

• Creating supplementary content opportunities

Building Your Podcast Journey

Transforming your podcast from hobby to thriving business requires dedication, strategic thinking, and unwavering patience. By following Gary Arndt's proven strategies, you can build a podcast that stands out from the crowd and generates sustainable income. Focus on creating genuine value, understanding your business metrics, and building dedicated fan communities that support your long-term goals.

Remember that success in podcasting isn't about overnight growth. Start where you are, improve consistently, and stay committed to serving your audience. With persistent effort and a clear vision, you can create a show that resonates with listeners and achieves substantial download numbers even in today's crowded podcasting landscape.

Key Takeaways:  

1. Forget conventional "niching down" advice if broader content serves your vision better

2. Create the show you'd want to listen to, not just what you want to talk about

3. Calculate your subscriber value ($10-14 annually) to guide acquisition spending

4. Invest in podcast app advertising rather than social media marketing

5. Publish daily content with substantial research (Gary's "2000-word term papers")

6. Build superfan communities that celebrate dedicated listeners

7. Use precise mathematics to determine where and how much to spend on promotion

8. Focus on mastering audio before expanding to video platforms

9. Be patient - substantial income typically takes 18+ months to develop

10. Know exactly what topics to avoid for your audience (Gary avoids politics)

 

Ready to start your podcasting journey? Get access to 50+ integrated podcasting tools with a free trial at PodUp.com.

Thanks for joining us in exploring these valuable insights from Gary Arndt's podcasting journey. Here's to creating content that matters!