In this episode of Podcasting secrets, I sat down with Mike Grabham, host of Whose Story Is It? and a seasoned entrepreneur. As a six-time founder and CEO coach with 25 years of experience, Mike has mastered the art of creating meaningful conversations through his innovative podcast format where guests remain anonymous until the big reveal. From growing and selling a travel magazine to launching a pioneering real estate software company, his journey as an entrepreneur has shaped his approach to creating meaningful podcast content.

Throughout our conversation, Mike shares candid insights about finding purpose through podcasting and the art of asking uncomfortable questions that lead to unforgettable stories. In this blog post, we'll explore five essential lessons from Mike's podcasting experience, helping you understand how to create a show that stands out and genuinely connects with your audience.

1. Create a Unique Format

Standard interview podcasts have become too common in today's market. Most hosts simply introduce their guest, ask about their background, and work through a predictable list of questions. This conventional approach makes it difficult to capture and retain listener attention.

Create specific elements in your show that break from the standard format. Consider keeping guest identities hidden until later in the episode, using unique segment structures, or developing signature questions that appear in every episode. These distinctive features help listeners remember and return to your show.

Test different format elements with your audience and measure their response. Look for ways to structure your show that serve both listeners and guests while setting you apart from competitors. Focus on creating moments that wouldn't be possible in a traditional interview format.

2. Ask the Uncomfortable Questions 

The best podcast moments often come from questions that hosts hesitate to ask. Surface-level questions lead to predictable answers, while uncomfortable questions create memorable content. Most podcasts stick to safe topics and standard questions, resulting in forgettable interviews that blend together in listeners' minds.

Learn to recognize when you're hesitating to ask something. That hesitation usually signals an opportunity for deeper, more authentic conversation. These challenging questions often lead guests to share personal insights and stories they've never discussed before. While asking about failures, personal struggles, or controversial decisions might feel awkward, these moments typically become the highlights of your episodes and create stronger connections with your audience.

3. Find Your True Purpose

Most podcasts start with surface-level goals like growing an audience or generating income. These motivations rarely sustain a show long-term. Your podcast needs a deeper purpose that drives every episode and decision. Starting a podcast just to gain followers or make money often leads to burnout and inconsistent content quality.

Consider what genuinely excites you about podcasting. Whether it's connecting with interesting people, sharing overlooked stories, or helping others learn from experiences, this core motivation keeps you going when challenges arise. The right purpose creates natural enthusiasm that comes through in your content and helps you push through difficult periods of growth.

A clear purpose also helps maintain authenticity in your content. Listeners can tell when a host is genuinely passionate about their show versus just going through the motions for views or sponsors. This authenticity builds trust with your audience and creates a stronger connection that surface-level content cannot achieve. When you're truly aligned with your purpose, content decisions become clearer and your unique voice naturally emerges.

4. Get in the Groove 

Consistent podcast quality requires establishing reliable recording routines and practices. Many hosts deliver inconsistent episodes because they lack structured preparation methods and pre-show systems. This unpredictability can quickly lead to lost listeners and missed opportunities with guests.

Develop specific pre-recording routines that work for you. This could mean reviewing guest research 30 minutes before recording, doing vocal exercises, or setting up your equipment in the same way each time. These routines eliminate technical distractions and help you focus entirely on creating great content.

Track when you record your best episodes and replicate those conditions. Some hosts perform better in the morning, others late at night. Pick a consistent recording schedule that matches your peak energy levels. Create a pre-show checklist covering everything from equipment setup to content preparation, and follow it every time.

5. Just Start Already 

The main barrier to podcast success isn't equipment, knowledge, or audience - it's hesitation to begin. Too many potential hosts get stuck in endless planning without taking action. This paralysis often comes from comparing yourself to established shows or feeling overwhelmed by technical requirements and content planning.

Start with what you have and learn through experience. Every successful podcast began with an imperfect first episode. The insights gained from actually producing content far outweigh theoretical planning. Your first episodes might not be perfect, but they provide real feedback and learning opportunities that no amount of preparation can match. Each recording session improves your interviewing skills, technical abilities, and understanding of what works for your audience.

Focus on getting episodes out rather than achieving perfection. Your show will naturally evolve and improve as you gain experience and feedback from real listeners. Many successful podcasters look back at their early episodes and see dramatic improvement over time. This growth only happens through consistent production and willingness to learn from each episode. The sooner you start, the sooner you can begin refining your craft and building your audience.

Your Podcast Journey Starts Here

Finding your podcast's purpose can be transformative for hosts looking to create meaningful content and build lasting connections with their audience. By following the five key lessons shared by Mike Grabham in his Podcasting Secrets episode, you can set yourself up for success in the world of podcasting.

Remember to:

1. Break away from conventional formats and create something unique

2. Push yourself to ask the uncomfortable questions that lead to powerful stories

3. Focus on finding a deeper purpose beyond just growing numbers

4. Establish your rhythm and stay consistent with your content

5. Start creating content rather than waiting for the perfect moment

By implementing these strategies and learning from experienced podcasters like Mike, you'll be well on your way to creating a podcast that truly resonates with your audience and fulfills your purpose. So, start today and begin exploring how your unique voice can make a difference in the podcasting world.

Key Takeaways:

1. Create a distinctive podcast format that breaks from conventional interviews

2. Don't shy away from difficult questions - they often lead to the most memorable content

3. Build your show around a genuine purpose beyond just growing numbers or making money

4. Establish consistent recording routines and practices for reliable content quality

5. Start creating content rather than getting stuck in endless planning

6. Use your unique perspective and experiences to shape authentic conversations

7. Focus on adding value to your listeners through meaningful content

---

If you're looking for a great all-in-one podcasting platform with 35 integrated modules, you can get a free trial at PodUp.com.

Thanks for joining us for this episode. Remember, your unique voice matters - now go start sharing it.